Welcome to Jerry and the Mermaid
At Jerry and the Mermaid, culinary innovation meets coastal charm. Nestled in Riverhead, NY, this New American seafood haven specializes in vibrant dishes that celebrate the ocean’s bounty. From Jerry’s Famous Buffalo Wings to Maryland-style Crab Cakes, every bite tells a story. The inviting atmosphere, complete with outdoor seating and a full bar, makes it perfect for gatherings or casual nights out. With its attentive service and diverse menu—offering a unique twist on seafood classics—Jerry and the Mermaid effortlessly creates a dining experience that captivates both locals and visitors alike. Dive in and discover the magic!
- 469 E Main St Riverhead, NY 11901 United States Hotline: (631) 727-8489
Welcome to Jerry and the Mermaid, where culinary creativity meets the shores of fresh seafood in a lively setting! Nestled at 469 E Main St in Riverhead, NY, this vibrant eatery embodies the essence of New American cuisine with a delightful blend of flavors, particularly focusing on the bounty of the sea. As you step into this casual yet captivating bar and restaurant, the inviting atmosphere is perfect for families, friends, and colleagues alike, making it an ideal spot for lunch or dinner.
- Reservations and Accessibility: Whether you're planning a casual evening out or a special gathering, Jerry and the Mermaid caters to your needs with reservations and ensures accessibility with an ADA-compliant entrance and parking facilities.
- Diverse Offerings: With options that range from tantalizing hot appetizers like Maryland Style Crab Cakes to the famed Jerry's Not Your Ordinary Buffalo Wings, there's something for every palate. Vegetarians will find limited options, but the seafood selection is enticing.
- Unique Features: Enjoy outdoor seating with views, a full bar to sip on your favorite cocktails, and a lively atmosphere well suited for dancing. Want to catch a game? TVs dot the space, making sure you don’t miss any action.
- Specials and Services: Dive into happy hour specials on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. The restaurant offers delivery, takeout, and even catering for your larger events, ensuring you get your favorite dishes wherever you are!
The menu is a celebration of flavors, and my experience was nothing short of exceptional. The Coconut Shrimp, lightly fried and rolled in coconut, paired with a tantalizing honey aioli, was a personal highlight, leaving my taste buds dancing. The Crispy Calamari, served with a choice of marinara, was another dish that came highly recommended—perfectly fried and bursting with flavor.
Backed by a team that emphasizes customer service, each bite is accompanied by friendly and attentive staff, ensuring that every visit feels personal. With plenty of on-site parking and even EV charging stations, accessibility here goes beyond just the physical space. Dogs are welcomed too!
In conclusion, Jerry and the Mermaid isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a destination filled with vibrant energy and culinary excitement. Whether you're indulging in the rich flavors of their signature dishes or catching up with friends over drinks, the experience promises to be memorable. Don’t miss the chance to enjoy a taste of the sea—reserve your table today at 631-727-8489!

The servers are the sweetest people. In love with their shrimp scampi pasta, and their fresh oyster is a plus. The atmosphere inside is very nice, I will definitely going back for my gateway to Long Island.

Another wonderful dinner at Jerry and The Mermaid. Jerry is a terrific and attentive host that checks in on all tables to make sure his patrons are happy. The fish as usual was fresh and cooked perfectly. Our server Kim recommended the ...

The servers are the sweetest people. In love with their shrimp scampi pasta, and their fresh oyster is a plus. The atmosphere inside is very nice, I will definitely going back for my gateway to Long Island.

Another wonderful dinner at Jerry and The Mermaid. Jerry is a terrific and attentive host that checks in on all tables to make sure his patrons are happy. The fish as usual was fresh and cooked perfectly. Our server Kim recommended the ...

Great place and nice food with healthy options. But felt a bit pricey, but the food was good, so not much complaints! ...

I went to this restaurant for the first time this evening. I work in the area and was looking for a nice place to have dinner with my husband after a hard day of work. It was easy to find. It is located next to the Hotel and the Riverhead ...

We came here for the first time and cant believe we havent been here before. Phenomenal meal. Oysters were very fresh and tasty. The buffalo shrimp was a really unique sauce and tasted amazing. My entree was the broiled combo cooked ...

This was a Michelin star experience! The presentation was exquisite followed by a mouthful of flavor. I stumbled upon this place by coincidence today not expecting much other than a simple lunch and WOW I was wrong, I wished I lived closer ...

We attended a private event here. The venue is awesome with excellent food! Chef Jerrys dishes are amazing and he is extremely personable. Tom, the bartender makes an amazing cosmo and our waitress, Lynn, provided nothing but the best service. Highly recommend!

The Staff ? The sweetest and kindest people in the industry. JO ANN WE LOVE U ! The owner not only runs a great restaurant hes a leader through and through. You can tell he is a great person by how happy his staff is and they are happy. ...